Henry Bull sold the eastern portion of Lot 2, Block I to Thomas White, a blacksmith, in 1859 (number 32 Church Street). The selling price noted in the deed abstracts is an indication that the property contained a house. In 1863, Bull sold his own residence, the modest frame house that still stands at 28 Church Street, to Frederick J. Dignan Smith, a young barrister whose presence on the property is indicated in the 1871 census.

1855 Joseph Tomlinson sold Lot 2, Block I, Plan 18 to Thomas Wilson - price: L34
1856 Thomas Wilson sold Lot 2 to Henry Bull - price: L450
1859 Henry Bull sold east part of Lot 2 to Thomas White – price $650
1863 Henry Bull sold west part of Lot 2 (his own residence) to Frederick Smith – price $350
1871 Frederick Smith sold west part of Lot 2 to William Smith
1891 William Macdonald sold west part of Lot 2 to Marion Purvis – price $600
1906 Marion and John Teece sold to Annie Cross – price: $550
1910 Annie Cross sold to William Ashman – price: $650
1914 William Ashman sold to Frederick Harvey – price: $1200
1915 Frederick Harvey sold to H. S. Snider – price: $1230
1922 H. S. Snider sold to Henry Churchill – price: $2300
1925 Henry Churchill sold to Charles and Mary Irish – price $1,000 plus mortgage